Human Rights First Human Rights First

Bahraini Students Forced to Choose Between Loyalty to the Regime and an Education

6-24-2011

By Stephanie El Rayess
Human Rights Defenders Program

Noor al-Derazy, who participated in a women’s leadership program funded by the US Department of State, tells the story of her expulsion from Bahrain Polytechnic University in a letter addressed to the CEO of her university.

Bahrain’s Ministry of Education has revisited its decision to stop funding the education of students who allegedly took part in what it refers to as “anti-Bahrain” protests. The U.K.-based newspaper, The Guardian, reported in April that the Bahraini regime revoked the grants of U.K.-based students who were photographed attending peaceful rallies in solidarity with the country’s pro-democracy movement and was harassing their families back home.

The ministry’s ‘reviewed’ decision was to pay the university fees of students who did not play a direct or significant role in the protests. As for the students who took part in the demonstrations, they were asked to sign a “loyalty pledge,” along with their parents, stating that they will obey the law. The statement by the Minister of Education, Dr. Majid Al Nuaimi, also includes stipulations for students currently abroad: they should either submit their signed pledge to Bahrain’s embassy in their country of residence or have their parents meet the ministry’s scholarship administration if they were living in countries that do not have Bahraini embassies. According to the Ministry of Education, the payments of “only 100” students, of the 7,400 students receiving government-sponsored scholarships for studying in Bahrain and abroad, were “temporarily” stopped.

“Going back is a great risk and staying here is difficult,” says Noor who believes she was identified as being part of the demonstrations in London through the pictures she posted on Facebook:

The Bahrain Center for Human Rights has voiced its concerns over the severity of the measures taken by the Bahraini government towards university students. The Center reported several violations to the right to education, including the dismissal of more than 160 students – mostly from the University of Bahrain, the arrest of 78 students, the revoking of the scholarships of students studying abroad, and 500 withdrawals (as of May 25) of students from the University of Bahrain due to the “politicized” and “hostile” environment on campus since classes resumed on May 2.

The Bahraini officials do not attempt to conceal the students’ right to education was violated because they openly expressed their political opinions. “The Bahrain Polytechnic has taken action against a number of students for political violations,” said Dr. Mohammed Al Asiri, the government-owned institution’s Vice Chief Executive Officer. According to the statement on the official website of the Ministry of Education in a ‘latest news’ article titled, Students Expelled, the duration of the expulsions ranged between a semester to a year, written warnings were issued to groups of students and no action was taken against students who “were not proven guilty” by specialized committees formed to investigate the case.

In her comments on Bahrain Polytechnic’s expulsions and warnings to a “few” students, Ministry of Education spokesperson Lubna Selaibeekh felt the need to point out that each student “costs the college” 60,000 Bahraini Dinar to complete his/her four-year program. She added that the government also covers 94% of Bahrain University’s tuition fees and provides full scholarships to over 2700 students through the Student Support Fund. Her message is clear: the Bahraini government is financially supporting the main educational institutions and expects students to “serve their kingdom” in return; the students owe the regime their loyalty and have to pay the price of expressing their solidarity with anti-regime protests.

Bahraini students, male and female, have been actively participating in demonstrations. This is hardly surprising for young educated adults with political and economic grievances. They have been among the targets of the most violent government crackdown on demonstrators as a result. What is surprising, however, is the Ministry of Education’s justification for violating the students’ right to education.

 


  • Lulwa

    Are you suggesting that the government continues to sponsor individuals who call for its downfall. Would the US govt sponsor students supporting AlQaeda or Islamic fundamentalism? They are valid ideals aren’t they? Students that do not show loyalty to the government that believed in them and invested in their future do not deserve to be supported it.

    • sarah

      Whether you like it or not, the US does in one way or another sponsor students who support AlQaeda’s beliefs because it is a democracy, and if you think about it this is what essentially led to the tragic events of 9,11 (not that I in anyway agree with this, but its true). Moreover, comparing AlQaeda to the Bahraini government is quite extreme, a more valid comparison would be a protest against the Obama administration, or the Bush one back in the day, and these do take place all the time. Democratic “anti-government” protests take place in the US (outside the white house to be more specific) all the time, the government has never attacked them or revoked their rights for education which is one of the basic human rights for everyone and this is agreed upon internationally. Everyone here has the right to express their opinion, no matter how extreme it is, that’s what freedom of speech is all about, is it not? These students represent part of the future society of Bahrain, and their pleas should be at least heard, I think, they should not be shut down and forced to show their obedience to a government they do not support…Every government gains more power by making use of opposite opinions and taking it as a chance for reform and growth…Retaliation leads to further retaliation, if we have learned anything from what has been happening all over the middle-east this year, it should be this!

  • Nawaf Al-Shaib

    I am sure that’s nothing from this article is right .
    Because everyone in this great kingdom take his/her rights .
    And Plz don’t talk about my country if you don’t know nothing .
    Because all of the people you are talking about have got more good then us .
    nd they don’t have a loyal to there country .
    so plz clear this article

    • sarah

      Yes, you are right, Bahrain is definitely one of the countries that values human rights the most, especially by all the benefits Bahraini people get, which is why I was absolutely shocked when I heard this, and more shocked when I actually looked for sources supporting this article, and they are there. I wonder if you have any sources that state that this is indeed not true or biased in some way? This would definitely help…as non of us live there at the moment and we are all aware of media bias, but it is important for us to see both sides of every story…Therefore, if you have those sources please go ahead and share them, I am sure all the readers would appreciate them!

  • joelle

    This article is clear depiction of the reality in Bahrain….something should be done about this. Keep this articles coming and keep us informed.