Human Rights First Human Rights First

Bahrain Reforms Generate Small Change

8-9-2011

By Stephanie El Rayess
Human Rights Defenders

“The mere fact that the king has appointed this commission and the Interior Ministry is cooperating shows me things have changed,” Cherif Bassiouni, head of the Bahrain Independent Commission of Inquiry, told Reuters on Thursday. But things have not changed enough for many Bahraini teachers, students and activists.

Jalila al Salman, teacher and Vice-President of the Bahrain Teacher’s Association (BTA), is still forgotten in prison. She was arrested in March for her alleged role in coordinating a teachers’ strike along with other BTA board members. Jalila decided to begin a hunger strike last week to demand her freedom and to protest her continuing torture and ill treatment while in custody. Jalila is not alone. She is joined by Roula al-Saffar, also awaiting trial in connection with the February and March protests. Roula, a cancer survivor and founder of the National Association for Cancer Awareness, is Head of Bahrain Nursing Society and Assistant Professor at the College of Health Sciences. She is accused of publicly defaming officials from the Salmaniya Medical Complex, the main public hospital in Bahrain where she is the Head of Nursing. She has repeatedly denied the charges against her.

Other female detainees are also serving sentences in harsh conditions. Mariam Mohamed Abdulla and Reem Ahmed Hilal, two young female students of the Bahrain Institute, were sentenced on April 1 for “having illegal messages or slogans on their phones when searched at a military checkpoint,” according to an urgent appeal Human Rights First (HRF) received. They had exchanged messages that were forwarded to them on their Blackberry phones. Mariam is yet to be released despite serving her three-month term, which, according to her mother, is causing her severe distress. As for Reem, she was sentenced to seven months in prison and is reportedly suffering from humiliating and degrading treatment.

The situation of students has not changed enough either. The Bahraini government had punished students who participated in protests by revoking their scholarships. Recently, honor students and their parents have been worried about the distribution of academic awards and scholarships for the 2011- 2012 school year. The names of the recipients of the scholarships were not officially announced, and the selection criteria were not made clear, according to reports sent to HRF. The Ministry of Education responded to “allegations of favoritism, sectarian abuse and cover-up. “The ministry said it followed Arab and international standards in selecting qualified candidates for scholarships based on their academic performance and their personality traits reflected in personal interviews conducted by specialists trained by the Bahrain Institute of Public Administration, insisting that there were no questions about any student’s sect or “sectarian remarks.” Human rights activists are voicing their concern over using scholarships as political tools to pressure students, warning about the negative effect of the increasing suspicion on the credibility of Bahrain’s educational system.

Bahraini women activists are still speaking out about human rights violations. Mariam al Khawaja, Head of Foreign Relations Office at the Bahrain Center for Human Rights, recently tweeted “Student Abdulhadi Nabeel Diwani was arrested upon return from his studies in the UAE, arrests are still ongoing.” In another recent tweet, a leading female activist, “angryarabia”, said that it is great that Bahrain’s Independent Commission of Investigation caused the release of 41 people as well as the suspension of a police chief and several officers as Bassioni mentioned in his interview with Reuters, but wondered “Is the price the truth?”.

Bassiouni said that about 300 people remain in detention over the widespread demonstrations earlier this year and that he hoped to secure the release of a further 150 in coming days. The release of several detainees -Matar Matar, the youngest member of the Bahraini parliament whose wife spoke to al-Jazeera about her fears ; Jawad Fairooz, who like Matar was a member of al-Wefaq’s parliamentary bloc that resigned following the government’s crackdown on protestors in February, and Mohammed al-Tajir, a human rights lawyer who has defended a number of activists – is an indication of the “good faith” of the Interior Ministry Bassiouni commended. But it is hard to see why these people were arrested or detained in the first place, and so their release – while welcome – should not be seen as a substitute for investigating and prosecuting those who have committed torture.


  • Hussain Al Sayed

    Hi,
    Bassiouni committee is a bribe, all of them are working to save Al Khalifa Regime. Lots of questions recently raised, but all of them ignored!!!

    Who is the one who is responsible in bringing Al Jazeera Trops to Bahrain?

    I don’t think this is a Personal Act

    Who is the one who is responsible in killing the 33 martyrs?

    Personal Act?? Feeding the Guns with a special bullets made specially to kill people, it’s a personal Act?

  • Liberal voice

    Bassiouni’s commission has got real results with most of the detainees freed and many people reinstated in their work. I can’t understand why you didn’t mention it in your article, but I suppose it doesn’t fit with your agenda.

    As for the human rights activists you chose to give voice to Maryam Al-Khawaja was attending a conference on the legacy of Khomeini a few months ago, which celebrating this mass killer’s ‘achievements’. You should ask this ‘women’s rights activist’ what Khomeini’s achievements on women’s rights were – like having thousands of women raped and killed by his security forces, as well as encouraging polygamy and temporary wives.

    The Bahrain Centre for Human Rights’ head Abdulhadi Al-Khawaja is a former cadre with the Islamic Front for the Liberation of Bahrain, an Iranian intelligence front. The Front targetted and murdered civilians in bomb attacks. The Islamic Front/Iranian intelligence angle might be why Maryam sent a message of support to the Khomeini conference. Why not ask her about it?

    As for the attacks on Bassiouni, who are you at Human Rights First going to believe on this: a former nominee for the Nobel Peace Prize or an organisation long headed by an ex-IFLB cadre?