Human Rights First Human Rights First

Holiday on ICE?

3-30-2012

By Annie Sovcik
Refugee Protection Program

Tell Congress: Invest in Alternative to Detention ProgramsWhat would you call the treatment of refugees who, fleeing persecution and seeking freedom, arrive in the United States only to be promptly handcuffed, shackled, and thrown in jail?

Some members of Congress call it a “holiday.”

The House of Representatives held a hearing yesterday called, “Holiday on ICE: The U.S. Department of Homeland Security’s New Immigration Detention Standards.” Clearly, several members of Congress are out of touch with the realities of immigration detention.

Take ActionTell Congress to prevent unnecessary detention and spending by investing in effective and less expensive Alternatives to Detention (ATDs).

Despite efforts to reform the system, asylum seekers in the United States who are fleeing persecution continue to be held in jail or jail-like facilities, despite years of bipartisan findings that such conditions are inappropriate for asylum seekers and other civil immigration detainees.

Immigration detention has increased rapidly in the past ten years, and it’s been costly. In fact, many immigration law detainees are deemed low-risk by the government and do not need to be detained at all. They are ideal candidates for effective and less expensive ATDs.

ICE spends $122 a day per detainee. That amounts to $2 billion every year. Current ATD programs, on the other hand, cost an average of $8.88 per person/day, more than $100 less per person/day

Take ActionTell Congress to be smart with taxpayers’ money and prevent unnecessary detention by shifting money away from detention and investing in ATDs.


  • Nick

    I’m speaking from the heart when I say this is a huge problem. I am currently writing from VIVE Inc. in Western New York which is a shelter for immigrants seeking entrance into Canada and the United States. These people who are seeking freedom and opportunity, are being jailed for breaking immigration laws, yes, but the women and children are being placed in prisons with the general criminal population. We’re talking about innocent people being placed with murderers and drug dealers! We need to hold fair hearings on the issue of detainment of men, women and children because these conditions are in violation of the U.S. constitution, the highest law in the land. We should be writing to our politicians asking them to take a positive stance on this issue!