UK
Government Commits to Public Inquiries in Northern Ireland Murders,
But Fails to Act in
Finucane Case
NEW YORK - The UK government today announced its commitment to establish
"as soon as possible" public inquiries into the case of
murdered human rights lawyer Rosemary Nelson, as well as two other
high-profile cases involving alleged collusion between members of
the UK security forces and paramilitaries in Northern Ireland.
In the case of lawyer Patrick Finucane, however, the government
did not commit to hold an inquiry, promising to revisit the issue
after the conclusion of prosecutions.
"Public inquiries in all of these cases are long overdue,"
said Michael Posner, Executive Director of Human Rights First. "While
the government's decision to abide by its commitments in the three
cases is a very positive development, the Finucane case should not
be singled out for further delay."
In making its announcement, the government published reports by
Judge Peter Cory into the murders of Nelson, Finucane, Billy Wright,
and Robert Hamill, in which the judge recommended public inquiries
in all four cases.
In regard to the Finucane case, Judge Cory found that: "If
criminal prosecutions are to proceed the practical effect might
be to delay the public inquiry for at least two years. The Finucane
family will be devastated. A large part of the Northern Ireland
community will be frustrated. Myths and misconceptions will proliferate
and hopes of peace and understanding will be eroded. This may be
one of the rare situations where a public inquiry will be of greater
benefit to a community than prosecutions."Human Rights First
shares Judge Cory's concern that there should be no further delay
in conducting a public inquiry into the killing of Finucane.
The publication of the reports come more than five months after
they were presented to the government by Judge Cory and a day after
their release to the victims' families.
Judge Cory, a retired Justice of the Supreme Court of Canada, was
appointed by the British and Irish governments in May 2002 to investigate
evidence of collusion in these four controversial cases from Northern
Ireland and two from the Republic of Ireland. Human Rights First
has long been campaigning for public inquiries in two of the cases-those
of human rights lawyers Patrick Finucane and Rosemary Nelson. Both
lawyers were known internationally for their work representing people
arrested under Northern Ireland's emergency laws.
The UK government should begin constituting public inquiries immediately,
consulting fully with the victims' families about their powers and
scope.
The Cory reports document collusion with illegal paramilitary groups
by members of the security forces, cover-ups, and many incidents
of superiors "turning a blind eye" to unlawful activity
by police officers in Northern Ireland. It is necessary to uncover
the truth and acknowledge violations in these cases in order to
create public confidence in the security service and the rule of
law.
Patrick Finucane was killed on February 12, 1989, when masked gunmen
broke into his Belfast home and shot him 14 times in front of his
wife and three children. Although the Ulster Defense Association,
a loyalist paramilitary group, claimed responsibility for the killing,
strong evidence has emerged linking three separate UK intelligence
agencies to the murder. Despite this, the UK has long resisted establishing
a public inquiry into the case, and no-one has been successfully
prosecuted for the killing.
Rosemary Nelson was killed on March 15, 1999, when a booby-trapped
bomb exploded under her car in Lurgan, Northern Ireland. Although
a loyalist paramilitary group claimed responsibility for the murder,
there are many questions about Ms. Nelson's death that remain unanswered.
In the years leading up to the murder, she had been harassed, assaulted,
and threatened by members of Northern Ireland's police force. Human
Rights First, along with other human rights organizations and UN
officials, had repeatedly warned the UK government that her life
was in danger. We urged senior government officials to take steps
to ensure her safety. Despite these efforts, the UK failed to take
adequate steps to protect Ms. Nelson. No-one has been prosecuted
for her murder.
|