Human Rights First - Home Page US Law & Security After September 11 2001 US Law & Security After September 11 2001

Human Rights First on John Walker Charges

Statement of Elisa Massiminoo: Director of the Washington, DC office of Human Rights First

January 15, 2002

The announcement of charges by the U.S. government against John Walker Lindh raises some serious questions. At this point, the most pressing is this: is the U.S. government following its own rules about due process, and in particular, about access to counsel?

Mr. Walker has been held on military ships in the Arabian Sea, since he was taken into custody. The lawyer retained by Walker’s family has been repeatedly denied access to him. Walker is an American citizen who is going to stand trial before a U.S. court on extremely serious charges. This is a case where the legal requirements are clear and they need to be clearly applied. The right to counsel is a core Constitutional right and the U.S. government needs to be scrupulous in following the law, especially in circumstances where the defendant has been detained for weeks without any judicial monitoring whatsoever.

The U.S. government should provide Mr. Walker access to his lawyer immediately. While the government has said that Mr. Walker waived his right to a lawyer, the Administration will have a heavy burden to demonstrate that Mr. Walker’s waiver was, under the conditions of his confinement, “knowing and voluntary.”

Anyone looking at Mr. Walker’s picture taken at the time would have serious doubts about his ability to make that kind of decision.


U.S. Law & Security | Torture | Asylum in the U.S. | Human Rights Defenders | Human Rights Issues | International Justice | International Refugee Policy | Workers Rights | Media Room | About Us | Contribute | Jobs | Contact Us | Publications | Search | Site Map | Home 

Privacy Policy